Ads Running But Tracking Wrong? Here's What's Happening
Your Google Ads campaigns are active. Traffic is coming to your site. Money is being spent. But when you look at conversion data, something feels off. Conversions are missing, numbers don't match what you expect, or Google says it doesn't have enough data to optimize.
This is the most frustrating scenario: Everything looks like it should work. Your ads are running. Your website is getting visitors. But conversion tracking is broken, so you can't tell if your ad spend is actually driving results. Google might still optimize your campaigns, but it's optimizing on incomplete or missing data—which means wasted budget.
The fear is real: Are you wasting money on ads that don't convert, or is tracking just broken? Here's how to know the difference.
Check If Tracking Is Breaking Your Ad Performance
Run a free scan to see if consent or tracking issues are preventing Google Ads from measuring conversions correctly.
Run Free Scan →The Paradox: Ads Work, But You Can't Prove It
Here's the frustrating reality: Your ads might actually be working. Traffic is coming. Sales might be happening. But if conversion tracking is broken, you can't see it in Google Ads. This creates a dangerous situation where you can't:
- Know which keywords, ads, or audiences actually drive conversions
- Optimize your campaigns based on real performance data
- Justify continued ad spend without conversion proof
- Scale what works because you don't know what works
- Stop wasting money on campaigns that don't convert
This is especially dangerous because Google Ads will still optimize—just not effectively. Without accurate conversion data, Google's algorithms make decisions based on incomplete information. You might be paying for clicks that don't convert, or missing opportunities to scale campaigns that actually work.
The worst-case scenario: You're spending money on ads that work, but you think they don't because tracking is broken—so you shut them down.
Or: You're spending money on ads that don't work, but tracking is broken so you can't tell—so you keep spending.
How Google Ads Optimizes Without Complete Conversion Data
When conversion tracking is broken, Google Ads doesn't just stop optimizing. It tries to optimize with whatever data it has—which can lead to poor decisions.
Here's what happens:
Optimization on Partial Data
Google sees some conversions but not all, so it optimizes based on incomplete information. High-converting keywords might get deprioritized because their conversions aren't being tracked, while low-converting keywords get more budget because their few tracked conversions look good by comparison.
Modeled Conversions (When Available)
If Consent Mode v2 is configured, Google can model conversions for users who don't grant consent. But if Consent Mode isn't working correctly, modeling doesn't happen—and you lose all that conversion data entirely.
Fallback to Click-Based Optimization
When conversion data is missing, Google might optimize based on clicks, engagement, or other signals instead of actual conversions. This leads to campaigns that drive traffic but not necessarily revenue.
Incorrect Bid Adjustments
Automated bid strategies need conversion data to work effectively. Without it, bids might be too high on unprofitable traffic or too low on valuable opportunities—wasting budget or missing revenue.
The result: Your ads run, but they're not optimized effectively. You're spending money, but you're not maximizing ROI because Google doesn't have the data it needs to make good decisions.
Why This Feels Like a Betrayal
When ads are running but tracking is wrong, it creates an emotional disconnect. You've invested time and money setting up campaigns. You're seeing traffic. Your website is getting visitors. But the data doesn't reflect what you expect, and you can't tell if your investment is paying off.
This situation is particularly frustrating because:
- Everything looks fine—Your ads are active, traffic is coming, nothing is obviously broken
- You can't verify results—Without conversion data, you can't prove ROI or justify continued spend
- Uncertainty breeds fear—Is money being wasted? Are campaigns working? You don't know
- Optimization feels impossible—How do you improve campaigns when you can't see what's working?
- Scaling is risky—Without data, increasing budget feels like gambling
The validation you need isn't about reassurance—it's about getting accurate data so you can make informed decisions. When tracking is broken, every decision feels like a guess.
💡 The good news: If tracking is the problem, it's usually fixable. Once conversion data flows correctly, you can finally see what's working and optimize with confidence.
Common Scenarios: What You Might Be Seeing
Here are common situations where ads run but tracking is wrong:
Scenario 1: Zero Conversions Despite Traffic
Your campaigns show clicks, impressions, and traffic—but zero conversions. This could mean:
- Conversions are happening, but tracking is broken (likely)
- Traffic isn't converting (also possible, but you can't tell which)
Without fixing tracking, you can't know if you need better traffic or just better measurement.
Scenario 2: Conversions Don't Match Expectations
You know sales are happening (from your e-commerce platform or CRM), but Google Ads shows far fewer conversions. This usually means:
- Partial tracking—some conversions are recorded, others aren't
- Attribution mismatches—conversions are attributed to different channels
- Consent blocking—conversions from users who reject cookies aren't tracked
Scenario 3: "Not Enough Data" Warnings
Google Ads shows warnings that there isn't enough conversion data to optimize effectively. This happens when:
- Conversion tracking is broken, so Google receives incomplete data
- Consent issues prevent conversion events from firing
- Tracking delays mean conversions aren't recorded in time for optimization
Scenario 4: Campaign Performance Declining
Campaigns that used to perform well are now showing worse results. This could be:
- Actual performance decline (market changes, competition, etc.)
- Tracking breaking over time (consent issues getting worse, code changes breaking measurement)
- Optimization on bad data leading to poor campaign decisions
How to Know If Tracking Is the Problem
The only way to know if tracking is breaking your ad performance is to test it. A diagnostic scan checks your site exactly like a user would, testing what happens with and without consent to see if conversion tracking actually works.
The scan verifies:
- Whether conversion tracking code is installed and configured correctly
- If conversion events fire after consent is granted (or are blocked before consent)
- Whether Consent Mode v2 is working to model conversions for non-consenting users
- If tracking scripts fire before consent, breaking the measurement chain
- Whether cookies set before consent invalidate tracking
If the scan shows FAIL or PARTIAL, tracking is likely breaking your ad performance. Fixing those issues should restore conversion data and improve campaign optimization.
If the scan shows PASS, tracking is working correctly—so any performance issues are likely related to traffic quality, ad creative, or landing page experience (not measurement).
Find Out If Tracking Is Breaking Your Ad Performance
Run a free scan to see if consent or tracking issues are preventing Google Ads from measuring conversions. Get instant results showing exactly what's broken.
Run Free Scan →Why This Validation Matters
When ads are running but tracking is wrong, you need validation that the problem is measurement—not performance. This isn't about reassurance; it's about getting accurate data so you can make informed decisions about your ad spend.
Knowing that tracking is broken (and how to fix it) means you can:
- Fix the measurement issue and finally see accurate conversion data
- Optimize campaigns based on real performance, not incomplete signals
- Scale what works with confidence, knowing the data is reliable
- Stop wasting budget on campaigns that don't convert (because you can now see which ones don't)
- Justify continued ad spend with proof that campaigns drive results
The uncertainty you feel right now is valid. Without accurate tracking, every decision is a guess. But once you know what's broken and fix it, you can operate with confidence.
Related resources: