ConsentCheck

Cookie Banner Not Blocking Tracking? The Hidden Problem

You have a cookie banner. It looks professional. It has accept and reject buttons. It appears when users visit your site. But here's the problem: Your tracking scripts are still firing before consent is granted. Cookies are being set immediately when the page loads. Your banner exists, but it's not actually blocking anything.

This is the most common compliance issue we see: Sites that think they're compliant because they have a banner, but the banner is purely cosmetic. Behind the scenes, Google Analytics, Facebook Pixel, and other tracking scripts fire immediately—completely ignoring the banner's purpose.

The assumption that a banner equals compliance is dangerous. Your banner might look fine, but is it actually doing its job? Here's how to find out.

Check If Your Cookie Banner Actually Blocks Tracking

Run a free scan to see if tracking scripts and cookies are firing before consent is granted.

Run Free Scan →

The Cookie Banner Myth: Appearance vs. Function

Many sites believe that having a cookie banner means they're compliant. But a banner is just a UI element—it doesn't automatically block tracking. The banner needs to be connected to code that actually prevents scripts and cookies from loading until consent is granted.

Here's what actually happens on most sites:

  1. Page loads → Tracking scripts fire immediately
  2. Cookies are set before user sees the banner
  3. Banner appears 1-2 seconds later
  4. User clicks "Accept" or "Reject"
  5. But tracking already happened—banner can't undo it

This violates GDPR, CCPA, and other privacy regulations because tracking happens before consent is obtained. Your banner exists, but it's not functional—it's just a visual element that doesn't control anything.

The fix isn't about redesigning your banner. It's about ensuring tracking scripts and cookies only load after consent is granted—which requires technical implementation, not just a banner design.

Why Cookies Set Before Consent Break Everything

When cookies are set before consent, they invalidate your entire consent mechanism. It doesn't matter if your banner has perfect wording, clear accept/reject buttons, or follows best practices—if cookies are already set, consent is meaningless.

Here's why this is a problem:

  • Legal non-compliance: GDPR and similar regulations require consent before non-essential cookies are set. Setting cookies first makes any consent banner irrelevant from a legal perspective.
  • Tracking breaks measurement: If cookies are set before consent, consent management platforms might block them retroactively, breaking your tracking and measurement entirely.
  • Invalid consent: Users can't make an informed choice about cookies that are already set. This makes any consent given after the fact technically invalid.
  • Conversion tracking fails: When tracking scripts fire before consent, conversion events get blocked or ignored, breaking Google Ads measurement.

The technical reality: Cookies need to be set conditionally, only after consent is granted. Tracking scripts need to load conditionally, only after consent is granted. This requires code changes—not just banner configuration.

⚠️ Having a banner doesn't mean you're compliant. The banner must actually prevent tracking until consent is granted.

Common Reasons Cookie Banners Don't Block Tracking

Here are the most common reasons why cookie banners fail to actually block tracking:

Tracking Scripts Load in <head> Tag

If Google Tag Manager, gtag.js, or other tracking scripts are in your HTML <head> tag, they load immediately when the page loads—before any JavaScript can check consent status. By the time your banner appears, tracking has already started.

Banner Is Purely Visual

Some cookie banners are just HTML/CSS elements that display messages. They don't actually connect to code that prevents tracking. The banner shows, users click, but nothing technically changes—tracking continues regardless.

Consent Management Platform Not Integrated

You might use a Consent Management Platform (CMP) like Cookiebot or OneTrust, but if it's not properly integrated with your tracking scripts, it can't actually block them. Scripts load anyway, and the CMP just collects consent data it can't use.

Third-Party Scripts Load Automatically

Many third-party integrations (chat widgets, analytics tools, ad scripts) load automatically and can't be controlled by your consent banner. Even if your banner blocks Google Analytics, these other scripts might still fire and set cookies.

Banner Appears After Page Load

If your banner is implemented with JavaScript that runs after page load, tracking scripts might fire during the initial page render. By the time the banner JavaScript executes, cookies are already set and tracking has already started.

How to Know If Your Banner Is Actually Blocking Tracking

You can't tell just by looking at your banner. You need to test what actually happens when a user visits your site without granting consent. Here's what to check:

  • No tracking scripts fire until user clicks "Accept" in the banner
  • No non-essential cookies are set before consent is granted
  • Reject button actually blocks tracking (not just hides the banner)
  • Accept button enables tracking properly after consent
  • Cookies and scripts only load after explicit consent

Manually testing this requires:

  1. Opening browser DevTools
  2. Clearing cookies and site data
  3. Loading the page and checking Network tab for tracking requests
  4. Checking Application tab for cookies set before consent
  5. Testing both Accept and Reject scenarios
  6. Verifying tracking actually changes based on consent choice

This is time-consuming and error-prone. A diagnostic scan automates this entire process, testing your site exactly like a user would and showing you exactly what happens before and after consent.

💡 Our scan automatically tests what happens before and after consent, showing you exactly what your banner is (or isn't) blocking.

Test Your Cookie Banner →

Why "Reject" Buttons Often Don't Work

Even when cookie banners have reject buttons, those buttons often don't actually do anything. Here's why:

Reject Button Just Hides the Banner

Many banners treat "Reject" as a dismissal action—clicking it just hides the banner, but tracking continues. This is non-compliant because tracking should stop when consent is rejected.

Tracking Already Started Before Reject

If tracking scripts fired when the page loaded, clicking "Reject" can't undo what already happened. Cookies are already set, tracking requests already sent. The reject button can't retroactively block something that already occurred.

Reject Doesn't Update Consent Mode

Even if reject technically blocks some tracking, if it doesn't update Consent Mode v2 to signal "denied" state, Google might still model conversions—which defeats the purpose of rejecting.

Essential vs. Non-Essential Cookie Logic Missing

Some banners reject all cookies, including essential ones (like session cookies), breaking site functionality. Others don't properly distinguish between essential and non-essential cookies, leading to partial blocking that doesn't actually comply.

A properly functioning reject button should: prevent non-essential cookies from being set, stop tracking scripts from running, update Consent Mode to "denied," and maintain essential site functionality. Most implementations miss at least one of these requirements.

The Impact: Why This Breaks Google Ads Tracking

When your cookie banner doesn't actually block tracking, it creates a cascade of problems that break Google Ads measurement:

  • Tracking fires before consent → Gets blocked by browsers or privacy tools → Google Ads never receives conversion data
  • Consent Mode never updates → Google thinks consent state is unknown → Can't model conversions correctly
  • Partial blocking → Some tracking works, some doesn't → Conversion data is incomplete and unreliable
  • Invalid consent → Legal compliance issues → Can't use tracking data confidently

The result: Your ads run, traffic comes in, but Google Ads can't track conversions reliably. Campaign optimization suffers. Ad spend is wasted. And you can't tell what's working because the measurement is broken.

The fix starts with ensuring your banner actually controls tracking—not just displaying a message, but actually preventing scripts and cookies from loading until consent is granted.

How to Fix: Make Your Banner Actually Block Tracking

Fixing a non-functional cookie banner requires technical implementation, not just design changes. Here's what needs to happen:

  1. Load tracking scripts conditionally—Only after consent is granted, not in the initial page HTML
  2. Set cookies conditionally—Only non-essential cookies should be blocked; essential cookies can load immediately
  3. Update Consent Mode on consent actions—When users accept or reject, update Consent Mode v2 signals
  4. Test reject functionality—Ensure reject actually blocks tracking, not just hides the banner
  5. Integrate with CMP properly—If using a Consent Management Platform, ensure it's connected to your tracking scripts

The exact implementation depends on your tech stack, but the principle is the same: Tracking must be prevented until consent is explicitly granted.

Find Out If Your Banner Actually Blocks Tracking

Run a free scan to see exactly what happens before and after consent. The scan shows you if tracking scripts fire, if cookies are set, and whether your banner is actually controlling behavior.

Run Free Scan →

Related resources: